What can David Beckham teach us about hedge fund seeding?

As part of our investment process, we take time to understand a hedge fund manager’s personal attributes: this month we discuss age and the role of youth.

‘You won’t win anything with kids’

Football pundit Alan Hansen criticizing Alex Ferguson’s young Manchester United side (Beckham, Scholes, Giggs, Neville) following their opening day defeat in the 95/96 English Premier League. They went on to win both the Premiership title and the FA Cup that year!

2 Years Old

The youngest ever Mensa members, Adam Kirby and Christina Brown.

13 years old

The youngest ever chess grandmaster, Magnus Carlsen, from Norway.

‘Almost everything that is great has been done by youth.’

Benjamin Disraeli

Alongside more standard factors that can drive hedge fund performance (access to data, research capabilities, risk management philosophy) we consider nuanced performance drivers such as personality, motivation, and lifestyle – through to even what car you drive.
As we diligence managers for our second portfolio of seeds, we noticed a trend of younger managers looking to launch – and so thought of exploring whether age matters when it comes to hedge funds.

Theoretical models have hypothesized that more experienced managers would take more risk as they get older, as knowledge and confidence in their abilities grew. Evidence from studies done on mutual funds, security analysts, and macroeconomic forecasters has supported this theory: older managers are more likely to take bold, aggressive actions while younger managers are more likely to herd and show more risk aversion. However, empirical evidence specific to hedge funds shows the opposite: older hedge fund managers tend to display lower returns and lower risk (Liang (1999), Edwards and Caglayan (2001)). So why are hedge funds different?

Top performing managers
Age at launch
Ken Griffin, 22 CitadelSeth Klarman, 25 Baupost
Ray Dallio, 26 Bridgewater Paul Tudor Jones, 26 Tudor
Eddie Lampert, 26 ESL Chase Coleman, 26 Tiger Global
Warren Buffett, 27 Buffett Partnership Michael Steinhardt, 27 Steinhardt Partners
Stan Druckenmiller, 28 Duquesne Lee Ainslie, 28 Maverick
David Einhorn, 28 Greenlight Cap Tom Steyer, 29 Farallon
Peter Davies, 29 Lansdowne Louis Bacon, 32 Moore Capital

Boyson (2003) posited that this is a function of the dynamics of the hedge fund industry compared to the mutual fund industry: hedge fund managers have more skin in the game and have more to lose if their funds fail – reputation, future career prospects, etc. Therefore, younger managers at the start of their careers are more diligent and driven to produce absolute risk-adjusted returns – arguably a key reason behind why younger managers outperform. This would not only imply that – all else being equal – one should prefer younger managers, but also prefer younger and smaller funds: both positive findings for us as a hedge fund seeder.

When one thinks of hedge fund ‘legends’ one does not immediately think of youth; most of these legends are well over 50 years old. However, it’s worth remembering that most of today’s legends launched their funds in their early 30’s or younger. As can be seen by the table above, many launched under the age of 30. In our list of the top lifetime P&L generators, the average age at launch is 33.
Anecdotally, our current manager pipeline for our next portfolio of seeds has an average age of 34. The type of manager that Stable looks for potentially biases us to a younger manager. As part of our investment process, managers are run through personality questionnaires to help us understand their background and mindset. A manager’s hunger, focus and desire to perform is assessed; alongside lifestyle factors such as how many hours a week they work, how they define success, or how they plan to compensate their team.

If one had to try to put numbers to it, our view is that your 30’s is a good decade to launch – you are still hungry, not too rich, and able to work very hard without concerns about health or energy levels. We find investor opinions around the ‘appropriate’ age for a hedge fund manager is idiosyncratic to allocator types (endowments and family offices go younger) and cultural differences (Americans go younger than Europeans).
Being too young may make investors concerned that they lack experience or maturity, having not been through a cycle or experienced extreme market environments. Being too old can also damage investor perceptions: is the manager still ambitious and hungry enough to make a new business work? Can they embrace new technology and understand new trends driving bottom-line growth and price action? Can they adapt well to different environments or are they set in their ways?

As an allocator of capital, we must also be aware of how younger managers affect our diligence process. Younger managers generally have shorter investment track records; and have usually worked as part of a team as opposed to being a lead Portfolio Manager. This means that there is less information for allocators to base investment decisions on. As a seeder, this difficulty is magnified – and so our diligence processes have been refined over the last decade to address this.
We are not ageist; we would never base investment decisions on age – it would be foolish to do so. Age is – by itself – not important. What is important is a manager’s hunger, mindset, personality, lifestyle, risk seeking behavior, experience and skill set – all factors which may have correlations with age.

1 Liang, B., 2001. Hedge fund performance: 1990-1999. Financial Analysts Journal, pp.11-18.
2 Edwards, F.R. and Caglayan, M.O., 2001. Hedge fund performance and manager skill. Journal of Futures Markets, 21(11), pp.1003-1028.
3 Boyson, N.M., 2003. Why do experienced hedge fund managers have lower returns. Version: November, 3, p.2003

What We’re Reading This Month

A Man for All Markets: From Las Vegas to Wall Street, How I Beat the Dealer and the Market

Edward Thorp

The true story of the mathematics professor who was one of the first card counters and also one of the first ‘quants’ in the hedge fund world.

View on Amazon

2018-11-20T14:40:10+00:00

Stable Asset Management Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority in the United Kingdom (Firm Reference No. 605903), and is registered with the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission as a commodity pool operator and is a member of the National Futures Association (NFA ID 0450610). Stable Asset Management is a Private Limited Company (Company No. 07471761), registered in England and Wales at 35 Great St Helen’s, London, EC3A 6AP. Stable Asset Management is a VAT registered company (VAT No. 115 3158 44).

By accessing this website, the pages contained on it, the information, and the material contained or described herein (the “website”), you acknowledge your agreement with, and understanding of, the following terms of use:

The information contained in this website is proprietary, and provided for information purposes only by Stable Asset Management. Nothing in this website constitutes an offer or solicitation by Stable Asset Management to provide products or services of any kind in any jurisdiction; including, but not limited to: investments of any kind such as securities, or investment fund shares, and investment, tax, accounting, or legal advice. Although Stable Asset Management constantly monitors and updates the information on this website, despite all reasonable care, data may subsequently have changed or be based on incorrect information from third parties. Stable Asset Management or any of its affiliates or partners do not make any representations, or offer any guarantees, as to the accuracy, timeliness, reliability, completeness or availability of the information and opinions contained on this website. You should appreciate that information sent through the internet can be accessed by unauthorized third parties. Stable Asset Management does not accept any responsibility or liability for the security of data whilst browsing this website, and does not guarantee that this website will not illegally be modified by third parties. Access to the information contained on this website may be restricted by laws and regulations to which the individual user is subject. The information on this website is not intended for persons who are bound by laws or regulations which prohibit the publication of or access to this information (by virtue of any grounds such as nationality or place of residence). Persons who are subject to such restrictions are not permitted to access this website.